Apollo 17 in 3D

The Apollo 17 landing site between the north and south massifs of the Taurus-Littrow valley rivals Hadley Rille for the title of most spectacular landing site, and features some of the most impressive photography. One of the best images was taken after the LM separated from the CSM and the two orbited in together in a spectacular flyby sequence, shown below left from the 16mm footage and below right from image AS17-147-22467.

India, the LRO, China and Japan all capture the landing site with varying degrees of resolution. The LRO’s version consists of several different sets of images, which is why it has a patchwork appearance. Top left is a zoomed and cropped version of the Apollo image, top right the LRO, bottom left JAXA, bottom right China. At the very bottom left is a Chandrayaan-1  image, which uses its 25m DEM on which is superimposed the mapping camera data, while bottom right is a partial view of the hills at the far end of the valley as seen by Chandrayaan-2.

By way of comparison I have overlain the best resolution pre-Apollo image of the site taken by Lunar Orbiter (LO 4078 H3) and also an Apollo 15 Metric Mapping Camera image on the Japanese data.

Hopefully it should be obvious that the lunar orbiter model of the surface shows nothing like the detail that can be found in either the modern images or the Apollo 17 orbital photograph. Even the relatively low resolution Chinese image contains more information.

So, once you land what you do is take photos, lots of them, and with those photos you can construct a panoramic view of the landscape at ground level, and those panoramas can be compared with the 3D models. We’ll just use LRO, Chandrayaan, JAXA and Chinese views. Let’s start with a post landing panorama.

Despite gaps and spikes in the data, the views recreated using these DEMs are clearly the same as the panorama taken by the Apollo astronauts.

The Apollo crew took numerous other spectacular views of the area, and they can all be matched with the DEMs available. This view, for example, is of the north massif from the LM.

As usual an excellent representation of the scene in both of the modern probes. The rock on the right of the Apollo image is not quite large enough to have registered on the altimetry, which is why it isn’t obvious on them. In the distance, however, is a much larger feature that was spotted on Apollo orbital images, and which were photographed on the ground. Below left is an image that appeared in the 1973 National Geographic article on the mission and it shows the extensive boulder trail that ended in a large rock that they examined in detail later. Top right below  is the LRO view of the same area, and below that on the left is Chandrayaan’s and on the rright JAXA’s.

The LRO boulder trail is clear, as it is on the Chandrayaan view. JAXA’s image is lower resolution, but the crater at the bottom of the hill can be seen clearly, and as can the point where the trail ends. The pattern if the ground at the top of the massif is also easy to make out in comparison with the Apollo 17 photograph, as well as the terrain around the crater at the bottom of the hill.

Across the valley from the north massif, and at the foot of the south massif, is a trench like feature known as Nansen, shown here.

Here’s how that looks in the JAXA, LRO, Chandrayaan and Chinese models.

Patchy data aside,all the views are in complete accord with the Apollo image.

The Apollo landing site at Taurus-Littrow is so impressive that you are far better off just exploring it yourself, so here are the links to the DEM’s I have created for you to do just that.




Apollo 15 Mapping Camera on JAXA DEM

Lunar Orbiter on JAXA DEM


Apollo Overview 3D Overview